The Justice System’s Disgusting Indifference to Murder and Attacks on Jews

Two weeks after the October 7 Hamas terrorist massacre in Israel, Samantha Woll, a 40-year-old Jewish woman, was found murdered outside her Detroit home with multiple stab wounds.

The man charged with the brutal slaying, Michael Jackson-Bolanos, was acquitted of first-degree murder in July. Weeks later, a deadlocked jury failed to convict Jackson-Bolanos on a similar count of felony murder. Instead, the suspect, whose attorney claimed he was “in the wrong place at the wrong time,” will spend 18 months in prison after the jury only convicted him on one count of lying to law enforcement.

Detroit police continue to claim there is no evidence that Woll’s murder was motivated by antisemitism.

At the time of her killing, Woll was serving as President of the Isaac Agree Downtown Synagogue, and was active in Democratic politics. Incidentally, her murder occurred in Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib (D-MI)’s district, where, just days prior to Woll’s body being discovered, the antisemitic lawmaker launched into another anti-Israel diatribe and falsely accused Israel of a deadly strike on a Gaza hospital that she said killed over 500 people (this was proven to be a complete lie on every account).

In November, Tlaib spoke about her “dear friend” on the House floor, calling Woll a deeply loved member of the “social justice community.”

Tlaib’s performative sorrow does little to deflect from acknowledging the Congresswoman’s outsize role in fomenting antisemitism. Moreover, the dearth of media noise and the judicial dismissiveness attached to Woll’s murder case comes against a backdrop of rising violence targeting Jews nationwide. In New York, hundreds of miles from Michigan, Orthodox Jews are routinely subjected to assault, harassment, and intimidation by criminals engaging in antisemitic thuggery.

Last Spring, a group of religious Jewish children were playing in front of a Brooklyn building when they were knocked down and punched by a Citi bike rider. To date, police have yet to find the attacker.

Just last week, 22-year-old Vincent Sumpter was charged with stabbing Yeshiva student Yechiel Michael Dabrowskin near Chabad’s headquarters, while shouting antisemitic screeds at the cohort of Jews gathered before fleeing the scene.

These are just a fraction of the violent attacks that have occurred against Jews in New York and nationwide. And while this latest incident resulted in an arrest, anti-Jewish hate crimes in New York often occur without the perpetrators facing any criminal consequences.

On its surface, the murder case involving interfaith advocate Samantha Woll shares little in common with the repeated attacks on New York’s Hasidic community. Yet, public apathy and judicial indifference over whether Woll’s killer will face any consequences for his brutality is tied to a similar disengagement in prosecuting crimes concerning the targeting of observant Jews.

For all her work with the Muslim community, it’s hard to believe that Woll’s murder would have been treated the same if she had been a part of any other racial or ethnic group besides Jews.

For Jewish Americans to retain faith in our Nation’s criminal justice system, those tasked with preserving the integrity of our judicial order must illustrate their willingness to treat felonies committed against Jews with the same degree of seriousness that is exercised for other minority communities.

The intimidating and hate-fueled pro-Hamas rallies unfolding across American campuses and in cities have inevitably contributed to the alarming spike in antisemitic incidents, which, according to the Anti-Defamation League, reached an all-time high last year.

While liberal lawmakers in places such as New York are quick to condemn these anti-Jewish episodes, their lofty language is seldom met with robust repercussions for the antisemitic agitators. And sometimes, their incitement against the Jewish State is actually what helps contribute to the sense that violence against Jews (and especially pro-Israel Jews) will be tolerated.

Indeed, Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg dropped charges for most of the pro-Palestinian Columbia University students who participated in seizing a campus building earlier this year and destroying university property.

Unsurprisingly, as Jews are cast as an oppressor class within the intersectional paradigm that guides the agenda of many officials and residents in liberal-run cities, US Jews of varying ideological persuasions must confront the reality that prosecutors, the policy, and government officials will often fail to take the necessary action to punish perpetrators if the victims are Jewish.

A grievance-based approach in many areas of the country to policy helps explain the distinction attributed to the swift but appropriate punishment given to criminals guilty of attacking people of other faiths, including members of the Black and Muslim communities, but not to Jews.

Back in 2021, not far from where Woll’s body was found, a white Michigan resident was sentenced to five years in prison for beating a Black teenager with a bicycle lock. Yet Woll has received absolutely no justice — and we must also question if her faith played a role in the jury being deadlocked.

In June, Manhattan DA Bragg announced that 40-year-old Gino Sozio would be serving nine years in prison for his role in a 2022 anti-Muslim hate crime. At that time, Sozio pulled out a knife and slashed the torso of a 22-year-old Muslim-American man, who required stitches and surgery following the despicable assault.

The growth of progressive protest movements over the last decade suggests that some of the same people participating in such leftist endeavors may serve as the next juror or judge to decide the fate of a suspect charged with committing a crime against a Jew.

It’s a troubling trend that has already touched Europe. The societal shifts consuming France likely contributed to Sarah Halimi’s killer, Kobili Traore, being excused from a criminal trial after he tortured the Jewish woman for hours in her own home before killing her in 2017.

To political ideologues, it matters little if one adheres to the Samantha Woll or Yechiel Michael Dabrowskin branch of Judaism. To them, crimes encompassing members of the Jewish community are telegraphed through an intersectional prism where Jews will always remain unremarkable figures outside of the ideological sanctum.

Irit Tratt is an American and pro-Israel advocate residing in New York. Follow her on X @Irit_Tratt